Is the ‘Sibilla Originale del 1890’ the same reproduction as ‘Sibilla Originale 1850’ or a different deck/reproduction? 

It looks virtually identical. (I do have the 1890, the 1850 is news to me.) They've rounded the corners, though:

https://moderatelyquicksilver.wordpress.com/2020/01/20/sibilla-originale-1850-a-review/

And it's matte. The 1890 is shiny like a polaroid.
I may need this new one. 😁

Edited October 21, 20214 yr by katrinka

From YT reviews, it seems that it’s the same deck but with a different card stock. I’ve been eyeing this edition for quite a while because I love Il Meneghello’s paper, but I don’t use my 1890 Sibilla that often, so I’m not sure if I should splurge on this one… The corners look kind of funky and jammed in all walkthroughs though🤨

This is actually a lovely, usable Sibilla on good stock, you get the lottery numbers, and it's dirt cheap, too:

https://smile.amazon.com/Every-Day-Oracle-Lo-Scarabeo/dp/0738711810

 

This one is getting hard to find, but it's inexpensive and it includes both the lottery numbers and reversed meanings printed under the titles in Italian. The backs are nothing to write home about, but it's still a good deck:

https://tarotbg.eu/en/dal-negro-and-masenghini-decks/522-la-vera-sibilla-8000831510206.html