Book Review: The Esoteric Tarot, by Ronald Decker
This is the second time I've read The Esoteric Tarot by Ronald Decker, and, universe permitting, it won't be the last. It's a good, interesting, worthwhile read. I dig it, and I recommend it to anyone with an interest in how our wonderful tarot came into being.
It's not without flaws, however. I'm going to couch that mild criticism in an aura of praise; to my knowledge, this is the first properly academic attempt to present a coherent theory of the deep sources, origins, and development of the tarot. It's a vast subject, which Decker covers in just 275 pages (plus copious notes); as such, it's hardly surprising that sometimes his explanations feel a little brisk and not as rigorous as they might be.
A subject of this magnitude should probably be some university doctoral thesis. The Esoteric Tarot has elements of such a thesis, and although it's still a little dry and academic in places, it nevertheless shines with lots of fascinating details and anecdotes. It's not a quick, flighty read, though; be prepared for some slow, concentrated study from time to time, as Decker occasionally goes deep, and rightly so.
So what is The Esoteric Tarot about? In short, it's a book which analyses the "invention", not just of tarot cards, but of playing cards in general; and the origins and development of the whole Western Mystery Tradition, astrology, divination, symbolism, Gnosticism (which Decker calls "Hermetism"); and of the intersection of both of these elements with the Jewish cabala, and the development of a Western Mystical version of the cabala which Decker dubs "Hermetic cabala", and the role which all these three elements play in the birth of the tarot as a divinatory tool.
It's ambitious; and, with a few creaks here and there, Decker makes a very compelling case. I accept, in broad brush, 95% of his theory; it's well elucidated and supported by ample documentation, and thoroughly believable. I found myself straining at a couple of propositions, namely his insistence that the early tarot deck had only 14 trumps, but then jumped to 21 a generation later; I found myself thinking this was maybe a supposition too far, and doubting its value. But that's just me.
The one striking shortcoming of the book, in my humble opinion, is its sudden dead-stop. Decker presents wonderful detail and analysis right up to Etteilla's groundbreaking deck, including an exhaustive analysis of the meanings Etteilla assigned to the minor arcana, and their very close association with Gikatilla's cabalistic text "The Gates of Light". We're all steaming along nicely, inspiring and entertaining, and I'm wondering what Decker's going to make of the 19th century, Levi, Papus, The Golden Dawn, Waite, Crowley...
And the book stops. The 20% of pages still to read are notes.
To be honest, crediting Decker properly with the huge work he's done on The Esoteric Tarot, I felt its curtailed scope was a missed opportunity. I appreciate that the 19th century is an encyclopedic task in its own right, and not really the subject matter for a chapter or two at the end of a book, but it could have at least received a treatment. However, after a quick search on Amazon, I discovered that Decker has already co-authored with Sir Michael Dummett "A History of the Occult Tarot", which covers the period 1870 to 1970, so I'm going to give that a look!
As it is, The Esoteric Tarot is a worthwhile and praiseworthy attempt to trace the sources, origins, and development of our beloved tarot, right up to the end of the 18th century, and I would recommend it to anyone interested in a serious, academic treatment of the facts and source material currently available to us. It also sports gorgeously evocative cover art by Kirsten Hansen Pott, and would grace anyone's esoteric book shelves.
The Esoteric Tarot, by Ronald Decker, Quest Books 2013
Edited by Shaira
0 Comments
Recommended Comments
There are no comments to display.
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now